Brooklyn pet store accused of illegally selling hundreds of puppies in new lawsuit

New York – New York Attorney General Letitia James has filed a lawsuit against a Brooklyn pet store, alleging it continued to sell hundreds of puppies despite a statewide law prohibiting pet stores from selling dogs, cats, and rabbits. The legal action targets Quality Canines Inc., which operates under the name Puppy Boutique, and accuses the business of repeatedly violating New York’s Puppy Mill Pipeline Act while continuing to source animals from commercial breeders commonly known as puppy mills.

According to the Office of the Attorney General (OAG), the investigation found that Puppy Boutique continued advertising and selling puppies for more than a year and a half after the law was enacted. The Puppy Mill Pipeline Act, which took effect in December 2024, permanently bans pet stores across New York from selling dogs, cats, and rabbits in an effort to reduce animal cruelty, discourage puppy mill operations, and protect consumers from purchasing animals suffering from hidden health problems.

Attorney General James said her office is seeking a court order to immediately halt the store’s alleged illegal sales.

“Pets are valued members of our families, and anyone who brings a new pet into their home deserves a healthy animal,” said Attorney General James. “Puppy Boutique illegally sold puppies to New Yorkers, exposing them to heartbreak and exorbitant veterinary bills for animals raised in inhumane conditions. My office will continue to enforce the Puppy Mill Pipeline Act to ensure that animals across the state are protected, healthy, and free from mistreatment, and that abusive breeders are stopped.”

The lawsuit outlines what investigators describe as an ongoing effort by Puppy Boutique to continue operating despite repeated warnings from state agencies. Officials say the business promoted puppies through multiple online platforms, including Instagram, TikTok, and websites such as thepuppyboutique.com and puppypetite.com. Social media posts reportedly featured photographs of puppies, information about available animals, and contact details encouraging prospective buyers to purchase them, actions the Attorney General argues violated the state law.

State officials say Puppy Boutique had ample notice that the law would soon take effect. In February 2024, the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets informed the business that the Puppy Mill Pipeline Act would become enforceable later that year. Despite that warning, authorities allege the company continued selling puppies after the law officially took effect in December 2024.

The Attorney General’s Office says it attempted to resolve the matter before filing suit. In January 2025, investigators issued a cease-and-desist letter directing the business to stop the alleged unlawful activity. Several months later, in June 2025, the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene also issued a cease-and-desist order.

Read also: Three RIT alumni join the university’s Board of Trustees

According to court filings, Puppy Boutique responded by claiming it had shifted its business model and was partnering with a newly created nonprofit organization that would facilitate dog adoptions from its storefront rather than direct sales.

However, investigators allege the arrangement failed to comply with state law. The Attorney General’s Office contends the nonprofit organization was not registered with the Department of Agriculture and Markets and continued obtaining dogs directly from breeders, including breeders identified as puppy mills. As a result, officials argue the operation remained in violation of the Puppy Mill Pipeline Act despite its claimed restructuring.

As part of the investigation, the Attorney General’s Office conducted an undercover operation in March 2025 to determine whether Puppy Boutique was still offering puppies for sale. Using a telephone number listed in one of the store’s online advertisements, an undercover investigator contacted the business and asked about purchasing a Maltese puppy.

According to the lawsuit, a Puppy Boutique representative confirmed that puppies were available and discussed pricing. After the call, the representative allegedly sent multiple text messages containing photographs of available puppies, pricing details, store hours, and a link to an Instagram page displaying additional dogs.

Investigators also say the representative assured the undercover buyer that the puppy “can be taken home the same day as you come down.”

The Attorney General argues that the undercover exchange demonstrated Puppy Boutique was continuing retail puppy sales despite multiple enforcement actions and clear legal prohibitions.

The Puppy Mill Pipeline Act was designed to address longstanding concerns over the commercial breeding industry. Supporters of the legislation argue that puppy mills often prioritize profits over animal welfare, raising dogs in overcrowded or unhealthy environments while selling them through retail pet stores. Lawmakers also said consumers frequently face unexpected veterinary expenses after unknowingly purchasing animals with serious medical conditions.

Read also: Driver seriously injured in one-car crash in Shawangunk

Deputy Senate Leader Michael Gianaris, who played a key role in advancing the legislation, praised the Attorney General’s enforcement efforts.

“From the start, Attorney General James has been a great partner in enforcing our Puppy Mill Pipeline Act,” said Deputy Senate Leader Michael Gianaris. “Her actions today continue to send a strong message that this law is taken seriously and violators will be held accountable.”

Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal, who sponsored the Puppy Mill Pipeline Law, also welcomed the lawsuit, saying businesses have had more than enough time to comply with the new requirements.

“As any reputable business should know, the Puppy Mill Pipeline Law, which I was proud to sponsor, has been in effect for more than a year and a half,” said Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal. “The law expressly forbids the sale of dogs, cats, and rabbits in retail pet stores, but apparently that was not an obstacle for Puppy Boutique. Sourcing dogs from cruel puppy mills and fleecing unsuspecting consumers to the tune of thousands of dollars per animal will not be tolerated in New York state. I thank Attorney General James and her team for their work in enforcing this law and pursuing the bad actors who flout the law despite the harm it causes to humans and animals.”

The Attorney General’s Office noted that the investigation benefited from the assistance of both the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets and the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. Officials from both agencies worked alongside investigators as they gathered evidence regarding the store’s alleged business practices and compliance with state regulations.

The case is being handled by Assistant Attorney General Deborah Diamant of the Brooklyn Regional Office under the supervision of Assistant Attorney General in Charge Michael Barbosa. Investigator Lorenzo Hernandez also assisted with the matter. The Brooklyn Regional Office operates within the Division of Regional Affairs, led by Chief Deputy Attorney General Jill Faber and overseen by First Deputy Attorney General Jennifer Levy.

If successful, the lawsuit would stop Puppy Boutique from continuing the alleged illegal sale of puppies in New York. The case also represents one of the latest enforcement actions aimed at ensuring compliance with the Puppy Mill Pipeline Act, as state officials continue efforts to eliminate the retail sale of animals sourced from commercial breeding operations and strengthen protections for both consumers and companion animals.