State Police arrest Saratoga Springs woman accused of helping facilitate a widespread counterfeit check fraud scheme

New York – A months-long fraud investigation in New York’s Capital Region has led to the arrest of a Saratoga Springs woman accused of playing a role in a counterfeit check scheme that stretched across several counties.

Investigators with the New York State Police announced that Caroline R. Garrity, 31, of Saratoga Springs, was taken into custody on March 30, 2026. Authorities charged her with criminal facilitation in the fourth degree, a class A misdemeanor, following what officials described as an extensive investigation into fraudulent financial activity.

The case began to unfold after investigators noticed a suspicious pattern. A single vehicle appeared repeatedly in connection with incidents involving counterfeit checks. Those incidents were reported in several locations across the region, including Albany, Rensselaer, and Schenectady counties.

Read also: Prime Capital Ventures CEO Kris Roglieri sentenced to nearly eight years in federal prison for multimillion dollar wire fraud conspiracy

As detectives followed the trail, the vehicle became a central piece of the puzzle. Surveillance, reports from financial institutions, and investigative work gradually linked the car to a series of fraudulent transactions carried out over time.

According to authorities, the vehicle had been rented from Albany International Airport on January 30, 2026. Records showed that Garrity had signed for the rental in her own name.

During questioning, investigators say Garrity initially denied involvement. However, the investigation later determined that while she rented the car, it was not intended for her personal use. Instead, officials allege that Garrity was paid to place the rental agreement under her name before handing the vehicle over to another individual.

That person, investigators say, later used the car while carrying out multiple fraudulent acts tied to counterfeit checks across the Capital Region.

Read also: Four presidents of Rochester Institute of Technology gather on April 10 to reflect on the university’s remarkable transformation over the years

Authorities believe this arrangement allowed the primary suspect to use the vehicle without their identity appearing in the rental paperwork. Investigators say such tactics are sometimes used in organized fraud schemes to complicate identification and accountability.

After gathering sufficient evidence, State Police arrested Garrity and transported her to the New York State Police Latham Barracks for processing.

Following the arrest, she was issued an appearance ticket ordering her to appear before the Colonie Town Court. Her court date has been scheduled for April 22, 2026.

Garrity was released after processing, according to authorities.

The investigation into the broader counterfeit check operation remains ongoing as State Police continue to examine additional evidence and potential suspects connected to the scheme. Officials have not yet released further details regarding other individuals who may have been involved.